Welcome Guest Login or Signup
LIVE CHAT | INSTANT MESSENGER | BOOKMARK
| LANGUAGE:
 
Google


Bookmark:
RSS 1.0     RSS 2.0

Page:  1 | 2 | Next >  Last >>
Total Views: 84 - Total Replies: 12

POSTED BY: CelticTiger on 09/26/2008 11:22:23


I have never heard of a definitive equivalent of Bunkai in taekwondo poomsae/hyung. Are any of you familiar with an explicit concept of Bunkai, and if so, what is the word for it.

And if there is not one, has your dojang developed its own?

Thanks in advance,

Daniel





--------------------------------------------------------------
교사 Yidan kumdo, Ildan taekwondo




POSTED BY: Baby_Huey on 09/26/2008 11:35:55


I'm not sure I am fully understanding the term, but I've stopped and shown people what certain techniques will do when teaching forms and it's done with me as well.  I don't know if there is a term for it or not, I just assumed it was part of teaching.





--------------------------------------------------------------
Exwrestler turned Martial Artist
Back To Top




POSTED BY: TKDragon on 09/26/2008 12:45:42


If I remember the term properly, I believe it is the process of breaking down the poomse into the defensive/counter senarios.

I don't know of any "standard" for this practice, we usually break down the lower patterns with the lower belts to illustrate what it is within the form they are practicing and why we do the patterns in the first place. By the time they advance to say Sa Jung, they usually have the idea.

Back To Top




POSTED BY: CelticTiger on 09/26/2008 12:57:26



Baby_Huey wrote:

I'm not sure I am fully understanding the term, but I've stopped and shown people what certain techniques will do when teaching forms and it's done with me as well.  I don't know if there is a term for it or not, I just assumed it was part of teaching.

Here's the Wiki.  It explains it pretty accuarately.  But I've never seen it, or an equivalent ever mentioned in Taewondo ever in over twenty years.  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bunkai

Daniel





--------------------------------------------------------------
교사 Yidan kumdo, Ildan taekwondo
Back To Top




POSTED BY: stone_tiger on 09/26/2008 16:06:42


When one practices individual techniques or one-steps, one is practicing Bunkai.  Notice how singular exercises, such as "right foot back, long front stance with a left hand lower-section block" is the same as in many poomsae.  Furthermore, when we pair off and practice blocks and strikes, we are practicing Bunkai.  Similiarily, poomsae are Bunkai for Korugi--a confrontation broken and slowed down.

If you eat a fruit that is sweet and colorful, but do not know the name, did you not consume it?





--------------------------------------------------------------
"The more the water, the higher the boat." Yamamoto Tsunetomo, Hagakure
Back To Top




POSTED BY: IcemanSK on 09/27/2008 16:08:34


The term is boon hae. I've heard others in Korean, but this is the most universal.

Back To Top




POSTED BY: TK-D on 09/27/2008 19:19:31


Yes google a Mr. Stuart Anslow. He has a great website & wrote a great book on this very topic. TKD Hae Sul.

Back To Top




POSTED BY: CelticTiger on 09/29/2008 12:41:20


I know Stuart on another MA forum.  Thanks for pointing me in his direction, TK-D.:)

Daniel





--------------------------------------------------------------
교사 Yidan kumdo, Ildan taekwondo
Back To Top




POSTED BY: stone_tiger on 09/29/2008 16:27:26


...I thought my reply was pretty good





--------------------------------------------------------------
"The more the water, the higher the boat." Yamamoto Tsunetomo, Hagakure
Back To Top




POSTED BY: CelticTiger on 09/30/2008 11:52:52


I thought your reply was good too:


stone_tiger wrote:

When one practices individual techniques or one-steps, one is practicing Bunkai.  Notice how singular exercises, such as "right foot back, long front stance with a left hand lower-section block" is the same as in many poomsae.  Furthermore, when we pair off and practice blocks and strikes, we are practicing Bunkai.  Similiarily, poomsae are Bunkai for Korugi--a confrontation broken and slowed down.

If you eat a fruit that is sweet and colorful, but do not know the name, did you not consume it?

But to my knowledge, in karate, bunkai is in addition to step sparring.  We do so in kendo in which it is also additional to bunkai.  We do taekwondo step sparring at our dojang, but this is not breaking down the individual forms so much as step sparring for specific attack defense scenarios.

What I'm thinkin of is the bunkai, or boon hae for each poomse in specific.

I do appreciate the response.

Daniel





--------------------------------------------------------------
교사 Yidan kumdo, Ildan taekwondo
Back To Top
01/09/2009
Page:  1 | 2 | Next >  Last >>



*** TKDspace.com | Your Online Taekwondo Community ***
Powered by phpFoX Version 1.6.20